In the rugged desert of Nevada, 1918, a man vanishes without a trace. A gambler, known for his big bets and even bigger roll of cash, disappeared after a poker game in Round Mountain. What began as a missing person case soon uncovered a darker truth—secrets, betrayal and a deadly gamble that no one saw coming.

---

TRANSCRIPT:

We’re in the rugged desert of Nevada. The year is 1918. A man vanished without a trace... and the search for him would uncover dark secrets, betrayal, and something even more ominous.

It’s February, and the small, dusty town of Round Mountain is rocked by the disappearance of John McWilliams. A gambler originally from South Dakota with a reputation for carrying large sums of money, McWilliams hadn’t been seen since he’d walked into a poker game the night before. The town's eyes turned to the nearby desert, where the search for him would uncover far more than anyone expected.

But before we dive into the mystery, let me introduce you to the man tasked with unraveling it all. His name was Jimmy Darrough—an investigator for hire, a man of the Western Shoshone tribe who spent much of his life in the remote regions of Northern Nye County. To many, he was the one you called when the law couldn’t, or wouldn’t, help. And in this case, the law had no answers.

McWilliams's wife, Mary Cole, desperate to find her missing husband, turned to Jimmy Darrough for help. And Darrough, with his sharp instincts and knowledge of the land, began his investigation.

The first clue came from an unexpected source—a single overshoe, half-buried in a shaft, and the other found abandoned in the sagebrush. Why were there freshy worn shoes without a human? This was the beginning of something darker. Something deliberate.

But who would want to hurt a harmless gambler, and why?

John McWilliams had been last seen the night before at a poker game in Round Mountain, a game filled with hardened players and questionable characters. One of those players was Henry Kruger, a man who, by all appearances, had a curious interest in McWilliams. Kruger and McWilliams had exchanged a few words during the game—nothing out of the ordinary, just casual conversation. But McWilliams had something that Kruger said he was interested in learning about: a mining claim in Shoshone Camp, just outside of town. A claim McWilliams had recently acquired, and one that Kruger seemed particularly eager to see.

As the game wound down, Kruger suggested they go see the property. McWilliams agreed, and the two men left together. That would be the last time anyone saw John McWilliams alive.

The desert is a harsh place, and Shoshone Camp, located just outside Round Mountain, was no exception. The two men made their way out there, Kruger presumably interested in McWilliams's new claim. But when they arrived at the property, something changed. What was supposed to be a peaceful look at a mining claim turned into something far more sinister.

You see, Henry Kruger had learned something important during that poker game: McWilliams carried a large roll of bills with him. A fact that was hard to miss in a town where cash was king. And Kruger knew exactly how to take advantage of that.

As McWilliams walked into one of the tunnels on the claim, Kruger acted. With cold precision, he shot McWilliams in the back with a shotgun, leaving him to die in the dirt.

But Kruger didn’t stop there. No, he had to cover his tracks. On his way back to town, he tried to dispose of any evidence that might link him to McWilliams's death. One of Kruger’s overshoes was thrown into a mine shaft, the other tossed carelessly into the brush. Now, you might wonder why Kruger would discard these overshoes. The answer is simple: some blood splattered on his shoes. But he underestimated one thing—Jimmy Darrough.

Darrough knew the land too well. He tracked the scattered pieces of evidence—finding both overshoes in the places where Kruger had tried to hide them. To Kruger’s misfortune, these small items would prove to be vital clues. The discarded shoes were unmistakably Kruger’s, and their discovery led Darrough to piece together the sequence of events, building a trail that eventually exposed Kruger’s guilt.

The investigation turned to Kruger’s home. There, authorities found many items that had been reported missing from McWilliams—things like his spectacles, though the cash was nowhere to be found.

Kruger was arrested, tried, and convicted for the murder of John McWilliams. But it wasn’t an easy road to justice. The town was divided, and the case became a point of contention, with many wondering if they’d ever see the full truth.

Kruger spent the rest of his life in prison, his parole denied time and time again. And in the end, he died behind bars, never facing the full wrath of what he had done.

As for Jimmy Darrough, the man who solved the mystery? We wouldn’t be doing our job if we didn’t take a sidebar to mention his remarkable life. As a leader of the Shoshone people, he helped his community secure land rights during a turbulent time in Nevada’s history. When the Yomba Allotment Land was designated, he moved his family to Reese River, where he lived out much of his days. He reached the extraordinary age of 106.

Back to the main story, the question lingers: Who was Henry Kruger, and what drove him to commit such a brutal crime? Was he a known troublemaker, or did he have a hidden side that only emerged under pressure? How did his personality and past shape his actions on that fateful day?

The mystery of John McWilliams’s death remains a story of betrayal, greed, and the unforgiving desert. In the end, Henry Kruger paid the price for his crime, but the desert, as it always does, kept its secrets.

---

Also check out:

Berg, L. R. (1942). A history of the Tonopah area and adjacent region of central Nevada, 1827–1941.

Nevada Expeditions. (n.d.). Round Mountain. Retrieved from https://nvexpeditions.com

Ancestry.com. (n.d.). John McWilliams (1857–1918). Retrieved from https://www.ancestry.com

Ancestry.com. (n.d.). Calvin McWilliams (1895–1993). Retrieved from https://www.ancestry.com

Find a Grave. (n.d.). James X. Darrough. Retrieved from https://www.findagrave.com

Check out our full podcast archive here.